Shelly wearing purple glasses, a purple patterned headband and purple top beside Sir Kit Kat, a fluffy white cat with one amber eye and one blue eye, in a cozy holiday baking kitchen with cookies, mixing bowls and purple kitchen accents.
Holiday baking, a little kitchen chaos, and one very important cookie supervisor. 💜🐾

Kitchen Chaos: Holiday Baking Without Losing Your Mind

There is something about holiday baking that makes me want to pull out the mixing bowls, flour, butter, sugar and every kitchen gadget I own. I love baking. I love creating recipes, experimenting with flavours, and deciding on a whim that today would be a perfectly reasonable day to make something I’ve never attempted before. Because apparently, having a perfectly good list of things to do isn’t enough. Sometimes you just need to add flour to the situation. 😂

But here’s the reality. As much as I love baking, pain and energy are often what stop me from doing as much as I’d like. I can have a whole day of baking planned in my head, recipes I want to create, and a kitchen full of ingredients ready to go, but my body doesn’t always get the memo. Pain can turn something I love into a much bigger undertaking, and when my energy runs out, it runs out. That’s something I’ve had to learn to work around, even when my enthusiasm is ready to bake an entire bakery.

And one of the things I love most about baking is creating memories in the kitchen with the Littles. Those moments aren’t about perfect cookies or everything turning out exactly as planned. It’s about the fun, the laughter, the little hands helping, the mess we make along the way, and those moments together that become memories long after the baking is done. Those are the things I treasure.

My holiday baking favourites usually include butter tarts and shortbread cookies. Those are two that I really enjoy making, but beyond that, I don’t have some elaborate baking list written out weeks in advance. I don’t sit down in September and decide exactly which cookies will be making their grand appearance in December. I tend to wake up, get an idea in my head, sit down early that morning and create the recipe I want to make. Then away I go!

That’s how I cook and bake. I like creating my own recipes and making things the way I want them. Most of my baking is from scratch, although I will happily use premade tart or pie shells to save myself some time. Let’s be honest, there is no medal waiting for the person who makes every single component from scratch. If a ready-made shell saves me a little energy and still gives me a delicious result, I’m perfectly happy with that. Nobody needs to know how much work I didn’t do. 😂

Of course, not every kitchen adventure turns out beautifully. I’ve burned things, undercooked things, and watched things collapse that were supposed to be standing tall and looking impressive. You name it, I’ve probably had it happen at some point. Sometimes a recipe comes together exactly as I imagined. Other times, the oven seems to have developed its own personality and decided that my plans were merely suggestions.

And that’s part of baking, too. Not every batch is going to be perfect. Sometimes you learn something, sometimes you adjust the recipe, and sometimes you just stand there looking at the results wondering where exactly things went sideways. If it still tastes good, we’re calling it rustic and moving on. 😂

One thing I’ve learned over time is that I don’t have to bake everything in one giant marathon. I spread it out over several days, and I freeze as much as I can. This is probably one of my biggest sanity-savers during the holidays. Baking ahead means I can enjoy making things without trying to cram every recipe into one exhausting day.

The freezer is a wonderful thing. You can bake ahead, package everything properly, freeze it, and bring it out when you need it. It gives you breathing room. It means that when the holidays arrive, you’re not trying to make six different recipes while also preparing dinner, cleaning the kitchen, answering the phone, and wondering why you thought this was a good idea in the first place.

I also love that baking can be for a little bit of everybody. Sometimes it’s for myself, sometimes for family and friends, sometimes to share or give as a gift. There is something nice about knowing that something you made is going to be enjoyed by someone else. But I don’t believe that means you have to turn yourself inside out to make it happen.

And that’s really what I want to say to anyone who feels overwhelmed by holiday baking: you do not have to do everything. You don’t need twenty kinds of cookies, a dozen squares, three pies, homemade bread, and a kitchen that looks like a holiday baking show. You don’t need to compete with anyone else’s holiday plans, and you certainly don’t need to hurt yourself trying to keep up with an imaginary standard.

Make what you can. Buy a shortcut when it makes sense. Spread the work out. Freeze things ahead. Ask for help. And if you only manage one batch of cookies this year, that’s perfectly fine. One batch made with a little joy is worth far more than a dozen batches made while you’re exhausted, sore, stressed and ready to throw the mixing bowl out the window.

I have to remind myself of that sometimes, too. I love creating and baking, and I can get carried away with ideas. My mind is often three recipes ahead of what my body is prepared to do. So I have to pace myself, take breaks, and accept that things may take longer than I planned. It doesn’t make me any less of a baker. It just means I’m working with the body I have, not the one I sometimes wish would cooperate.

Holiday baking should be about enjoying the process, sharing something delicious, making memories, and having a little fun along the way. It shouldn’t become another obligation that leaves you completely worn out before the celebrations even begin.

So whether you’re making butter tarts from scratch, using a premade pie shell, baking one batch of shortbread, or filling your freezer weeks ahead of time, do what works for you. There is no single right way to do holiday baking.

And if something collapses, burns, or comes out looking nothing like the picture? Well, there’s always next time. Or a little icing sugar. Icing sugar can hide a surprising number of baking crimes. 🤣

I’d love to know what your must-make holiday baking favourites are. Are you a butter tart and shortbread person, a cookie-making machine, or someone who decides what to bake based on whatever happens to be in the cupboard that morning? And please tell me I’m not the only one whose baking adventures occasionally go completely sideways!

Life isn’t about waiting for the storm to pass… it’s about finding reasons to smile while the rain is still falling.

Stay kind.
Stay grateful.
YOU Matter!
Shelly 💜